If you obtain a lower rate after booking, please call us first. See Customer Care for details.
Find Nearby Properties

mm/dd/yyyy

mm/dd/yyyy

0

0
Adults (ages 19+)
Children (ages 0 - 18)
Room 1









Salisbury Hotel, New York, NY

Salisbury Hotel

Star rating: 2.5 of 5
123 W 57th St
New York, NY, 10019
866-539-0036
Average Rating
4.4
Recommend
95%
711 Guest Reviews

from $279.00

Lowest avg. nightly rate

This rate first available on Sunday, Nov 15

Select a Room & Rate Price Match Guarantee

Review Details for Salisbury Hotel:

  • 95% Recommend
  • 4.4 Average Rating
  • 711 Guest Reviews
Hotel Service
4.4
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
4.3
Room Cleanliness
4.5

Nothing is more important than the opinions of our guests.

Post a Review Review FAQs

Average Rating by Reason for Trip:

Select the reason for trip to view only those reviews

All Trip Types
(711 ratings)
Average Rating 4.4 of 5
Business
(98 ratings)
Average Rating 4.2 of 5
Romance
(55 ratings)
Average Rating 4.6 of 5
Family
(205 ratings)
Average Rating 4.5 of 5
With Friends
(154 ratings)
Average Rating 4.6 of 5
All Others
(199 ratings)
Average Rating 4.3 of 5

Filter Individual Reviews By:

Sort Reviews by:

Next Next Page 1 of 48 Previous Previous
Trip Type: Special Event Review 1 of 714
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
great location

The location was great, in between two subway lines. I was able to walk to wherever I needed to go. Even though the hotel was somewhat old, there's nothing really to complain about. The only thing I could complain about was that the elevators were slow.

 
Trip Type: Not Provided Review 2 of 714
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
4.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
4.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (1)
No (0)
Great room and location and price

My sister and I stayed in a standard room for 5 nights in late October.It was LARGE,included a refrigerator/microwave and coffee pot.We were two blocks from Central Park and there were grocery stores;wine shops;restaurants within one block of us.It really was a very comfortable stay.Minor inconvenience was the ice machine on the third floor(we were on 12) as I said minor. We would certainly stay there again.

 
Trip Type: Not Provided Review 3 of 714
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
3.0
Hotel Condition
3.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
4.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (1)
No (0)
Good Value for NYC

The rooms were large and the closet space was terrific. The beds were comfortable. There is quite a lot of street noise.

 
Trip Type: Not Provided Review 4 of 714
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (1)

Guest did not leave a comment.

 
Trip Type: Family Review 5 of 714
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
3.0
Hotel Condition
3.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
4.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (1)

Guest did not leave a comment.

 
Trip Type: Special Event Review 6 of 714
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
4.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
4.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (1)
No (0)
Excellent location for Carnegie Hall Events

Room was clean and comfortable. Would stay at this hotel again. Only issue is available parking lot is 2 blocks away on 56th street.

 
Trip Type: Family Review 7 of 714
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (1)
No (0)
Great room for the money

Good location near the Central park. Good service!

 
Trip Type: Not Provided Review 8 of 714
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (1)
No (0)
Great Room for the money

Great location for Central Park, Lincoln Center

 
Trip Type: Family Review 9 of 714
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
4.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
4.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (1)
No (0)
Great hotel

We had two huge rooms in our suite. Hotel was very comfortable and quiet.

 
Trip Type: Family Review 10 of 714
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (2)
No (0)
old NYC in great location

This has it all (for us) - old NYC charm, care, cleanliness, & spaciousness without the glitz of a Hilton, etc. It was simple and perfect, including location.

 

Not Recommended

Trip Type: With Friends Review 11 of 714
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
2.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (1)
No (0)
Great Location

This hotel was one block from Central Park South and was withing walking distance to restaurants, etc. There's a continental breakfast offered for six dollars and is well worth it. The condition of the hotel is satisfactory - old but clean. It was a good deal for the money, but I would probably pay a little extra next time and stay somewhere else.

 
Trip Type: Special Event Review 12 of 714
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
5.0
Hotel Condition
3.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
4.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Great room for the money

We had 3 rooms at the Salisbury. I have stayed in New York before and my rooms were very small. All three rooms were very large with a living room area, bedroom and bathroom. Refrigerator and microwave were also included. We loved the large rooms. Very nice location. Overall it was a great room for the money.

 
Trip Type: Family Review 13 of 714
Overall Rating
5.0
Hotel Service
4.0
Hotel Condition
5.0
Room Comfort
5.0
Room Cleanliness
5.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
Great for the Money

The Salisbury Hotel is so-o-o centrally located. On the left when you walk out the hotel are two reasonable restaurants. On the right one block down is a supermarket and their are two subways at the end of the block. Drugstore one block; Central Park two blocks -- you can see it from the corner. I highly recommend the breakfast -- much better than I anticipated -- well tended and good assortment. The help at the front desk was very helpful. I definitely know where I will be staying if I ever get back to New York. Older hotel than has been updated -- spacious!!!!

 
Trip Type: Special Event Review 14 of 714
Overall Rating
4.0
Hotel Service
4.0
Hotel Condition
4.0
Room Comfort
4.0
Room Cleanliness
4.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)

Guest did not leave a comment.

 
Trip Type: With Friends Review 15 of 714
Overall Rating
3.0
Hotel Service
3.0
Hotel Condition
2.0
Room Comfort
3.0
Room Cleanliness
2.0
Was this review helpful?
Yes (0)
No (0)
great location

Loved the location of the hotel and the fact that it is a classic old style. The drawbacks are the carpets which in our room ( especially the closet ) smelled like dog pee. The continental breakfast was cheap and everything fresh and tasty. For the price they should be able to change the old gross carpets.

 
 
Next Next Page 1 of 48 Previous Previous

Reviews and ratings contained within this site are the subjective opinions of customers and suppliers; they do not represent or reflect hotels.com's position. Neither hotels.com nor the parties involved in providing review content shall be held liable for any damages of any sort resulting from use of these reviews.